Tom Christofferson’s spiritual journey as a gay man took him from Mormonism, out, and back again. Rima Tamaiparea-Puki’s spiritual journey as a gay man took him from Catholicism to Mormonism and back to Catholicism through the Reformed Old Catholic Church. Both stories attest to stories of deep faith and religious devotion. Both stories speak to the need in all of us to be reconciled in one way or another to the faith of our families.